Insights

Restaurant POS Subscription Audit: A By-Location Checklist for Multi-Unit Groups

By Mitchell Nolan, Basis Point Hospitality ·

Educational checklist. Lawsuit figures below are allegations from an Oct 29, 2026 FTC and state complaint, not findings. Confirm your own contracts with counsel. Last checked: Nov 9, 2026.

Quick answer

A POS and restaurant-tech subscription audit checks every location's bill and contract against what you think you bought. List each MID or location's plan, terminal count, add-ons, renewal date and notice window. Then check early-termination math, closed-store minimums and whether "$0 hardware" plans still carry fees. Do it before the non-renewal deadline, not after the auto-renew posts.

TechnologyPOSVendors· 9 min read

Why multi-unit groups audit POS subscriptions now

On October 29, 2026, the FTC and several states filed a complaint alleging that auto-renewing restaurant POS subscriptions can carry hard cancellation paths, undisclosed early-termination fees, unconsented add-ons and "$0" pricing that was not actually $0. Whatever POS and restaurant-tech stack you run — terminals, KDS, online ordering, payroll add-ons, guest apps — the same audit questions apply across 20+ MIDs or locations where add-ons and renewals drift. This page is about what you pay today by location. When you choose to change terms after the audit, use the POS contract negotiation guide.

What the Oct 29 complaint alleges (context only)

The figures in this table are allegations from an ongoing case filed October 29, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (Case No. 3:26-cv-12705). They are not findings. Your contracts may differ. This page does not advise anyone to sue or switch vendors.

What the Oct 29, 2026 FTC and state complaint alleges (allegations only; not findings)
TopicWhat the complaint alleges
Subscription shapeAuto-renewing 1- or 2-year terms, billed monthly
Average monthly costAround / over $900 per month depending on terminals and add-ons (press-release wording; amount redacted in the public PDF)
Add-onsTimekeeping, payroll processing/tax filing, and other bundles without clear consent in some cases
"$0" / Pay-as-you-Go"$0" hardware/software claims; full retail hardware due if payments don't start within 120 days
Temporary closure$85/month still due in some plans
Early termination$150 per remaining contract month
Non-renewal noticeWritten notice ≥30 days before term end; online enroll ≠ online cancel
Payroll add-on cancelAlleged ≥90-day written notice path

Sources: FTC press release, Oct 29, 2026 · Complaint, FTC et al. v. Toast, Inc. et al., No. 3:26-cv-12705 (N.D. Cal. filed Oct 29, 2026) · San Francisco City Attorney release, Oct 29, 2026

One Sources line under the table names the case caption so readers can find the filing. The checklist that follows is vendor-agnostic and works for any POS or restaurant-tech subscription.

The checklist (by location / MID)

1. Inventory every location

Legal entity, DBA, address, MID(s), POS vendor(s), plan name (traditional vs pay-as-you-go / "$0 hardware"), terminal and handheld count, KDS/kiosk counts, online-ordering module, payroll/timekeeping add-ons, guest app. Who signed, and on which email.

2. Pull 3–6 months of invoices

Separate: software subscription, payment processing, hardware financing or "recovery," add-ons, support, minimums. Match invoice lines to the signed order form.

3. Map the renewal calendar

Initial term end date, auto-renew length, written non-renewal deadline (count back 30 days — or whatever your agreement says; the complaint alleges 30 days' written notice for the core subscription and 90 days for a payroll add-on). Put the deadline on a shared ops calendar. Missed notice = another term.

4. List every add-on and who approved it

Timekeeping, payroll, marketing, loyalty, online ordering, gift cards, and similar. Flag anything not on the original order form or not approved in writing by the location or regional owner.

5. Read the "$0 hardware" / promotional plan math

If the plan advertised $0 hardware or $0/month software, list what you actually pay (higher per-transaction fees, hardware clawback after 120 days of no processing, temporary-closure minimums). Compare to a traditional subscription quote on the same terminal count — comparison only, not a switch recommendation.

6. Price a hypothetical early exit

Using your agreement: early-termination fee per remaining month × months left, plus any hardware return / retail-value clauses, plus loan acceleration if a vendor loan is tied to staying on the platform. The complaint alleges a $150 per remaining month early-termination fee at the provider named in that filing — always use the number in your contract.

7. Closed and seasonal stores

For any location temporarily closed or sold: are you still paying a monthly minimum (the complaint alleges $85/month in one plan during temporary closings)? Who owns the obligation after a transfer?

8. Cancellation channel test (read-only)

Note whether you can cancel the same way you enrolled (online vs phone/chat + written notice + forms). Don't cancel anything from this page — document the path for counsel and procurement.

9. Cross-check payroll add-ons against payroll cost reduction

If payroll or timekeeping rides on the POS bill, reconcile to the restaurant payroll cost reduction checklist; don't double-count savings ideas.

10. Owner and cadence

One owner for the portfolio (finance or ops). Re-run the inventory quarterly and 45 days before every renewal notice deadline. Feed locations that clear the audit into the vendor rebid calendar or the POS contract negotiation page when you choose to act. For a wider non-food cost process, see restaurant vendor cost reduction. For payment-line detail on statements, see the merchant statement audit checklist.

What this checklist doesn't cover

Negotiating new POS contract language — that is the POS contract negotiation guide. Annual rebid of unrelated vendors (waste, internet) — the vendor rebid calendar. Payment interchange and MCC coding — use settlement, MCC and statement-checklist pages; this page does not re-teach them. Legal advice on whether any vendor violated the law. No outcome predictions on the FTC case. Telling operators to leave a named vendor.

How Basis Point Hospitality helps

BPH inventories POS and restaurant-tech subscriptions location by location, matches invoices to order forms, maps renewal and non-renewal deadlines, and flags add-ons, promotional-plan math, early-exit costs and closed-store minimums for counsel and procurement. Store operations stay the same. Our model: we find $1, you pay us 20 cents. POS and software subscriptions are one of the vendor relationships BPH reviews under the franchisee profitability program.

Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions

  • An inventory of every location's POS and software plan, add-ons, renewal dates, notice windows and exit costs, matched to invoices and the signed order form.

  • Audit is what you pay and when notice is due. Renegotiation is changing terms — see the POS contract negotiation guide.

  • A contract charge for ending before the term ends. One October 2026 FTC and state complaint alleges $150 per remaining month at a major provider — use your own agreement's number.

  • Transaction fees, hardware clawback if processing does not start by a deadline, temporary-closure minimums, and early-termination math.

  • Whatever your agreement requires. The FTC complaint alleges at least 30 days' written notice before term end for the core subscription, and a longer written path (at least 90 days) for some payroll add-ons.

  • The audit will show drift (add-ons, promotional plans, closed-store minimums). Consistency is an ops decision; BPH does not prescribe a single vendor.

  • No. It is an audit checklist. Any switch needs its own diligence and counsel review.

  • The October 29, 2026 FTC and state complaint and related press releases. They are allegations. See Sources.

Takeaways

  • Audit POS and restaurant-tech subscriptions by location or MID, against invoices and the signed order form.

  • Put every written non-renewal deadline on a shared calendar; missed notice usually means another term.

  • Treat "$0 hardware" and promotional plans as full cost of ownership, including clawbacks and minimums.

  • Price any early exit from your agreement; complaint figures are allegations and examples only.

  • Re-run the inventory quarterly and 45 days before each notice window; then decide whether to renegotiate or rebid.

Talk to BPH

Talk to BPH. We find $1, you pay us 20 cents.

Bring 3–6 months of POS/software invoices, order forms and renewal dates for every location.

Talk to BPHOr estimate your number with the restaurant savings calculator

Or estimate your number with the restaurant savings calculator

Book a diagnostic