Status as of Nov 17, 2026: Not in force. The court granted preliminary approval on June 9, 2026. The fairness hearing on final approval was held Nov 16, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York; Judge Brian Cogan did not rule and deferred his decision. No final-approval order has been entered. This page will be updated when the court rules.
Sources: official settlement website and Reuters, Nov 16, 2026 (both checked Nov 17, 2026); Payments Dive, Oct 16, 2026.
At a glance (last updated November 17, 2026)
Status: proposed, not in force; hearing held, ruling pending. Next date: none announced; a decision on final approval is pending. Exclusion: the official settlement website states that merchants cannot exclude themselves from this class. Your processor’s markup and fees: not addressed by the settlement. Guest checkout: no change required.
This page is a plain-language summary of public court records and news coverage for multi-unit restaurant operators. It describes proposed terms that are not in force. It is not legal advice. For the program view of card costs, see the restaurant payment processing optimization hub.
Where the settlement stands today
The case is In re Payment Card Interchange Fee and Merchant Discount Antitrust Litigation, No. 05-md-1720, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York. Visa and Mastercard are the defendants. This settlement covers the equitable-relief (rules) class: it would change network rules rather than pay out a cash fund (official settlement website).
June 2024: an earlier version of the rules settlement was denied preliminary approval (ABA Antitrust Law Section summary).
November 10, 2025: the parties moved for preliminary approval of an amended settlement (memorandum of law, ECF No. 9692, filed Nov. 10, 2025).
June 9, 2026: the court granted preliminary approval of the amended settlement (official settlement website).
September 2026: objections were filed ahead of the September 14 deadline, including a joint letter from merchants and trade associations and separate objections from large merchants that include a due-process challenge to the lack of opt-outs (Green Sheet, September 14, 2026; Payments Dive).
July 2026: class plaintiffs filed their motion and memorandum of law in support of final approval (official settlement website).
October 2026: Visa and Mastercard filed a joint reply to the objections, urging final approval (Payments Dive, October 16, 2026).
November 16, 2026: the fairness hearing on final approval was held in the Eastern District of New York. Judge Cogan did not rule and deferred his decision; he said rejecting the settlement could lead to a protracted process if the case went to trial.
Next: a ruling on final approval is pending, then possible appeals. As of November 17, 2026, nothing in the settlement is in force.
What the settlement would change, if approved
Credit interchange rates. Under the proposed terms, which are not in force, each network would reduce its systemwide average effective credit interchange rate by 0.1 percentage point (10 basis points) for five years, freeze posted credit rates at March 31, 2025 levels for five years, and cap standard consumer credit card interchange at 1.25% for eight years (Superseding and Amended Settlement Agreement; memorandum of law, ECF No. 9692). These are proposed court-record terms, not Basis Point Hospitality estimates, and they are not in force. Interchange is also only one layer of what a restaurant group pays to accept cards.
Card acceptance by category. Under the proposal, merchants could choose to accept or decline certain credit card categories (for example commercial, premium, or standard consumer credit) instead of being required to honor all cards of a network (official settlement website; ABA summary). Proposed, not in force. Objecting merchants and trade associations argue this has little practical effect for most businesses; that is their position, and the court has not ruled on it.
Surcharging and discounting. The proposal would broaden merchants’ rights to surcharge credit cards, capped at the lesser of 3% or the merchant’s cost of acceptance (official class notice, citing Settlement Agreement ¶¶ 40–41, 89–90). Proposed, not in force. State surcharge laws would still apply either way. Whether to surcharge or cash-discount is a separate, guest-facing decision; the cash discount vs surcharging decision framework covers it, and this page does not recommend one.
What it would not change
The settlement addresses network rules and interchange. It does not set your processor’s markup or discount rate, per-item and authorization fees, monthly, statement, gateway, and PCI fees, monthly minimums, or equipment charges. It does not fix downgrades caused by how transactions qualify, and it does not correct merchant category coding. Multi-unit fleets carry much of their avoidable card cost in exactly these layers; the four layers of a merchant statement are explained in the merchant services fees guide.
Pricing model matters too. On interchange-plus pricing, a change in interchange is visible as its own line. On bundled, tiered, or flat pricing, a lower interchange cost may not pass through to you automatically, because the processor sets the bundled rate. That is a method point, not a forecast: the only way to know is to read your own statements before and after any change.
Qualification and configuration fixes, covered in the interchange optimization guide, do not depend on the court at all.
What objectors argued
Objecting merchants and trade associations raised three broad arguments in their September filings, as reported (Green Sheet; Payments Dive). Basis Point Hospitality summarizes them here without taking a position.
Temporary relief: the proposed rate reductions are time-limited, after which rates could rise again.
Room for new fees: the proposal may not prevent the networks from adding or raising other network fees that offset the reductions.
Mandatory class: because merchants cannot opt out of this rules class, some objectors argue the settlement raises due-process concerns.
The court will weigh these objections at or after the fairness hearing.
What could happen next
The judge has not ruled, and Basis Point Hospitality does not predict the outcome. The court could grant final approval, in which case appeals could still delay any rule change. It could indicate that approval depends on changes to the agreement. Or it could deny final approval. Even after final approval and any appeals, changes would reach merchants only once the networks update their rules and notify merchants, so the practical timeline depends on all three steps (memorandum of law, ECF No. 9692: rules relief would take effect 90 days after final approval).
What a 20+ unit group can do now, before any rule changes
None of these steps require a ruling, and none change guest checkout.
1. Baseline effective rate by MID now: total fees divided by card volume for every merchant ID and location, using the method in the multi-unit merchant statement audit checklist. If rules change later, the baseline shows whether anything actually reached your statements.
2. Identify the pricing model on each MID and whether interchange appears as its own line.
3. Ask your processor in writing how a future interchange change would pass through under your current pricing, and keep the answer on file.
4. Work on qualification and configuration today: downgrades, channel flags, enhanced data, and coding. Start from the interchange optimization guide.
5. Do not reprogram terminals or start surcharging because of headlines. Nothing is in force, and surcharging is a separate decision covered by the cash discount vs surcharging decision framework.
Sources
Official settlement website (Rule 23(b)(2) class, No. 05-md-01720, E.D.N.Y.)
Superseding and Amended Class Settlement Agreement
Memorandum of law in support of preliminary approval, ECF No. 9692 (filed Nov. 10, 2025)
ABA Antitrust Law Section, Summary of the November 2025 Proposed Settlement
Green Sheet newswire, September 14, 2026 (objections)
Payments Dive, October 16, 2026 (Visa and Mastercard reply urging final approval)
This summary reflects public sources as of November 17, 2026 and will be updated when the court rules. It is not legal advice.
For a separate state-level case, see Illinois's law on interchange on sales tax and tips.
Frequently asked questions
Frequently asked questions
No. As of November 17, 2026, it has preliminary approval (granted June 9, 2026) but not final approval. The fairness hearing was held November 16, 2026, and Judge Brian Cogan deferred his decision. Changes would apply only after final approval, after any appeals, and after the networks update their rules.
No ruling yet. The final-approval hearing was held on November 16, 2026 and Judge Brian Cogan deferred his decision. Until the court enters a final-approval order, nothing in the settlement is in force and card acceptance rules and fees are unchanged.
If approved, it would trim some credit interchange for a period. Processor markup, per-item and monthly fees, and qualification problems are separate layers, and they decide much of what a multi-unit group pays.
The official settlement website states that merchants cannot exclude themselves from this equitable-relief class. Some objectors have challenged that in their filings.
The proposal would expand surcharging rights within a cap, but state laws still apply. Surcharging is a guest-facing decision that is separate from statement work.
Under the proposal, merchants could choose to accept or decline certain credit card categories rather than all of them. How practical that would be is disputed by objectors.
No. A baseline now shows whether any future change actually reaches your statements, and markup, fee, and qualification issues can be addressed today.
Continue the review
Multi-Unit Merchant Statement Audit Kit
Work out your effective card rate for every MID and every location in one afternoon, then see where the fleet's spread really is.
What's inside
- PDF checklist: what to pull, the 14-point MID checklist, fee layers and the network-update check
- Excel workbook: effective rate by MID and by location, ranked automatically
Takeaways
The swipe-fee settlement is proposed, not in force; the fairness hearing was held November 16, 2026, and no ruling has been made.
If approved, it would change some credit interchange and acceptance rules, not processor markup or fees.
Baseline effective rate by MID now so you can see whether any future change reaches your statements.
Do not change surcharging or terminals on headlines; nothing changes at guest checkout.
BPH’s diagnostic is free. If you move forward, the model is simple: we find $1, you pay us 20 cents, on realized savings and new revenue. No savings, no fee.
Explore the program
Restaurant payment processing optimizationRelated reading
Multi-Unit Merchant Statement Audit Checklist: Effective Rate by MID and LocationInterchange Optimization for Restaurants: What Multi-Unit QSR Groups Can Fix Behind the GuestCash Discount vs Surcharging for Multi-Unit Restaurants: A Decision FrameworkBook a free diagnostic
The diagnostic is free. We find $1, you pay us 20 cents — on realized savings and new revenue. No savings, no fee.
Book a free diagnostic