Insights

What Multi-Unit Restaurants Pay on Debit Cards: Regulated vs Exempt Debit and Routing

By Mitchell Nolan, Basis Point Hospitality ·

Debit cards issued by large banks fall under the Federal Reserve’s debit interchange cap; cards from smaller, exempt issuers do not. Routing rules also let many debit transactions travel over more than one network. Two federal appeals courts have now heard challenges to the cap and neither has ruled, so the current rule remains in force, so you can measure debit cost per MID now.

PaymentsExplainer· 7 min read

At a glance (last updated October 23, 2026)

Current rule: the Federal Reserve’s debit interchange cap (Regulation II) remains in force for large issuers. Fed proposal to lower it: published in 2023, not finalized. Court challenges: the Sixth Circuit heard argument on October 22, 2026, and the Eighth Circuit heard a separate challenge in May 2026; neither court has issued a decision. Guest checkout: no change.

This page summarizes public regulatory and court information for multi-unit restaurant operators. It is not legal advice.

How debit costs differ from credit

A debit transaction carries the same layers as credit: interchange paid to the issuing bank, network assessments, and your processor’s markup and fees. What differs is the interchange layer. Credit interchange is set by the networks; debit interchange from large issuers is limited by federal regulation. The four layers of a statement are explained in the merchant fee layers guide.

For credit-side context, see the credit card swipe-fee settlement guide.

Regulated vs exempt debit

Regulated debit: cards issued by banks above the regulation’s asset threshold are subject to the Fed’s interchange cap (Federal Reserve, Regulation II).

Exempt debit: cards from issuers below the threshold are not subject to the cap, so their interchange can be higher. If a meaningful share of your guests carry exempt cards, your blended debit cost will reflect it.

Prepaid and other categories have their own treatment under the regulation. Check how your statements classify them rather than assuming.

Routing in one minute

Federal rules require debit cards to be enabled on more than one unaffiliated network, which gives merchants a routing choice on many transactions. Whether your setup uses that choice well is a configuration question covered in least-cost debit routing in the interchange optimization guide.

Seeing debit cost on your statements (per MID)

1. Split debit volume and fees from credit for every merchant ID and location, using the effective rate by MID method in the multi-unit merchant statement audit checklist.

2. Where the statement separates regulated from exempt debit, record each.

3. If it doesn’t, ask your processor in writing for a debit breakdown by layer and keep it on file.

Where the debit-cap litigation stands

In August 2025, a federal court in North Dakota held that the Fed’s cap exceeded its authority and vacated it, then stayed that ruling pending appeal. The Eighth Circuit heard that appeal on May 13, 2026, and had not issued a decision as of October 23, 2026 (Eighth Circuit docket No. 25-3000).

In September 2025, a federal court in Kentucky upheld the same rule. A restaurant operator appealed, and the Sixth Circuit heard argument on October 22, 2026 (Sixth Circuit No. 25-6038). The central question is which issuer costs the Durbin Amendment lets the Fed count when it sets the cap. Press coverage reported that the judges questioned how fully the Fed had defined issuers’ incremental processing costs, and whether any fix should come from the court or be sent back to the Fed (Bloomberg Law, October 22, 2026; America’s Credit Unions, October 23, 2026). No decision has been issued, and the court did not say when it will rule.

Separately, the Fed’s October 2023 proposal to lower the cap has not been finalized (Federal Reserve press release, October 25, 2023; Federal Register).

Nothing changes for merchants until a final rule or ruling takes effect. Basis Point Hospitality does not predict outcomes. This section will be updated when either court rules.

What this does not change

Guest checkout stays the same. Surcharging rules for debit differ from credit; the surcharging and cash discount rules page covers the decision framework. This page does not recommend either.

Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions

  • A Federal Reserve rule, Regulation II, that limits the interchange large issuers can receive on debit transactions. It implements a provision of the Dodd-Frank Act.

  • Debit from issuers below the regulation’s asset threshold. It is not subject to the cap, so its interchange can be higher.

  • Not yet. The Fed’s 2023 proposal to lower it has not been finalized, and two federal appeals courts have heard challenges without ruling yet. As of October 23, 2026, the current cap remains in force.

  • On October 22, 2026, the Sixth Circuit heard argument in a restaurant operator’s appeal of the Kentucky decision that upheld the Fed’s debit cap. Press reports said the judges questioned how the Fed defined issuers’ processing costs. The court has not ruled, and the current cap remains in force. Any change would apply only after a final ruling or rule takes effect.

  • Rules require debit cards to be enabled on more than one unaffiliated network. How your setup uses that is worth checking; see the interchange optimization guide.

  • Split debit fees and volume per MID from your statements, or ask your processor for a breakdown by layer.

Multi-Unit Merchant Statement Audit Kit

Work out your effective card rate for every MID and every location in one afternoon, then see where the fleet's spread really is.

What's inside

  • PDF checklist: what to pull, the 14-point MID checklist, fee layers and the network-update check
  • Excel workbook: effective rate by MID and by location, ranked automatically

We use your email to send this file and, if you opt in, occasional margin insights. We never share it.

Takeaways

  • Large-issuer debit is capped by federal regulation; exempt-issuer debit is not.

  • The cap remains in force; the 2023 proposal is unfinished and two appeals have been argued but not decided.

  • Split debit from credit per MID to see what you actually pay.

  • The diagnostic is free. We find $1, you pay us 20 cents, on realized savings and new revenue. No savings, no fee.

Book a free diagnostic

Book a free diagnostic

The diagnostic is free. We find $1, you pay us 20 cents, on realized savings and new revenue. No savings, no fee.

Book a free diagnostic
Book a diagnostic